The four ways up, and what each is for
Access equipment splits into machines that carry a small platform to the work (aerial lifts, which the standards now call mobile elevating work platforms or MEWPs) and structures that put a large platform beside the work for as long as it takes (scaffolding). Within the machines, scissor lifts go straight up, boom lifts reach up and out, and mast climbers ride a mast fixed to the building. Each has a job it does better than the others.
| Option | Best for | Reach | Weak spot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scissor lift | One or two workers on a firm, level surface doing overhead or wall work that moves along: ceilings, MEP, glazing, painting, fit-out. | Platform heights of 19 to 40 ft on slab models, 26 to 50 ft on rough terrain. | Straight up only. Cannot reach over a parapet, a duct run or a machine. |
| Boom lift | Reaching over or around something: façades, steel, signage, tree work, anything above 40 ft. | Platform heights of 30 to 185 ft; articulating booms bend around obstacles. | One small basket. Slow for work that runs along a wall for days. |
| Mast climber | Masonry, cladding and window work on a long, tall façade where crews and material stay up all day. | Effectively unlimited with tie-ins; platforms 30 to 100 ft wide. | Engineering and erection time; not for short jobs. |
| Scaffolding | Continuous access for several trades over weeks, material staging at height, stairs, enclosure, anything the machines cannot fit under or around. | Any height with engineering. | Erection and dismantle labour, and a plan. |
The first guide, Scissor lift vs boom lift vs scaffolding, turns that table into a decision you can make on the phone with a supplier.
The six guides
- [Scissor lift vs boom lift vs scaffolding](/lifts-and-access/scissor-lift-vs-boom-lift-vs-scaffolding). The decision itself: reach, surface, duration, crew size and what each costs per week of access.
- [Types of boom lifts](/lifts-and-access/types-of-boom-lifts). Articulating vs telescopic, towable, rough terrain, electric vs diesel, and the platform heights each class covers.
- [Scissor lift sizes and platform heights](/lifts-and-access/scissor-lift-sizes-and-heights). The 19, 26, 32 and 40 ft classes, slab vs rough terrain, capacity, machine weight and door clearance.
- [Aerial lift rental cost](/lifts-and-access/aerial-lift-rental-cost). Day, week and month rates by machine class, the extras on the invoice, and when buying beats renting.
- [Aerial lift certification and training](/lifts-and-access/aerial-lift-certification-and-training). What OSHA and ANSI A92.24 require, operator vs occupant training, and what a card does and does not prove.
- [Aerial lift fall protection and safety](/lifts-and-access/aerial-lift-fall-protection-and-safety). Harness rules on booms, guardrails on scissors, the pre-use inspection and the mistakes that end up in incident reports.
Where scaffolding still wins
A lift is a machine that moves one small platform. A scaffold is a structure that holds a large one still. That difference decides most jobs. If the work runs the length of a wall for three weeks and three trades need to be up there at once, a frame scaffold or system scaffold costs less per worker-hour of access than any lift, and it carries the material too. If the work is a day of ceiling fixings in a warehouse, a 19 ft scissor lift is on the slab and working before a scaffold crew has unloaded the truck.
- Several trades working the same elevation at once: scaffold.
- Material stored at height, or a hoist landing: scaffold.
- Enclosure, weather protection or containment: scaffold, with sheeting or shrink wrap.
- Stair access for the public or for crews carrying tools: stair towers.
- Soft ground, slopes or no room for outriggers where a lift cannot set up safely: scaffold.
- Work that moves along or up and down all day with one or two people: lift.
Many of the suppliers on the map rent both. If you are not sure which you need, describe the job in a quote request and let two or three of them price it both ways.
The rules, in one paragraph
Federal OSHA regulates boom-type aerial lifts on construction sites under 29 CFR 1926.453, which requires training, fall protection tied to the boom or basket, and staying inside the rated load. Scissor lifts are treated as mobile scaffolds under 1926.452(w), so their guardrails are the fall protection and the scaffold training rule applies. In general industry the parallel rule is 1910.67. The industry consensus standards are the ANSI A92 series: A92.20 for how the machines are designed, A92.22 for safe use, and A92.24 for training, which is what a rental company means when it says your operators must be trained. The certification guide and the fall protection guide cover both in detail.